Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Oh no he didn't

Me, age 40


Every month, I read O magazine for my Oprah fix. I derive a curious pleasure in dissecting what she knows for sure (her words, not mine), how she lives her best life (ditto), and what “Aha!” moments she has stockpiled for my personal edification.

The September 2014 issue is chock full of good stuff. I’m sifting through Oprah’s advice for smart, simple makeovers when I land on Dr. Phil McGraw’s column. His topic is “The way you do anything is the way you do everything.”

“Well, this sounds fascinating,” I say to myself, cheerfully tucking into his article.

Dr. Phil explains that the phrase “The way you do anything is the way you do everything" has become his own personal credo. He writes: “I observed that I was an all-or-nothing person. If I was lazy about just one thing, my attitude contaminated all that I touched… On the other hand, if I aimed to be my best in one area, that commitment raised my game across the board.”

“I like this.” I say. “You’re on to something, Dr. Phil!” After all, who can argue with the suggestion that we bump up all of our efforts to be as productive and excellent as possible?

“You might want to take a look at the areas in your life that could use some improvement,” Dr. Phil says, ticking off bad habits like amassing credit card debt, passing the buck at work, and eating too much junk food. “Even the smallest change can help you turn things around… Start by taking better care of what’s around you.”

“OK, that sounds easy enough,” I respond. But Dr. Phil is just getting started.

“Has your window screen been torn for the last three years?” he asks me.

“Damn,” I whisper. “How does he know that my window screen has been torn?”

“Fix it,” he says.

“Sure,” I say. “As soon as I fold the six loads of clean laundry sitting in my family room and buy my kids their costumes for Halloween.”

Dr. Phil remains impassive.   

I read on. “Is your car a disaster?” he asks me.

“Oh, HELL NO,” I retort. “We are not bringing my car into this.”

Dr. Phil stares at me from the magazine page with a frosty smirk.

“I’ve always been honest about the fact that my car is a disaster. I try to keep it tidy, but it’s a losing battle. How can I ferry my three kids around with their snacks, backpacks, water bottles, soccer balls and dance gear and not have it resemble a landfill?” I ask.

But Dr. Phil does not care to hear my excuses. “Clean it up,” he says.

“Jerk,” I say.

“If you don’t live your life as if everything matters, you’ll never become everything you’re meant to be,” he adds.

“Dr. Phil, your personal credo is bunk!” I yell. “It looks fine on paper, but in practice it’s ridiculous!” Who does this guy think he is? He is certainly not a mother. If Dr. Phil were a mother, he would implicitly understand that not everything matters.

What does matter: that my children are healthy, clean, fed and educated; that they go to bed every night smothered with kisses and knowing they are loved. The rest is just icing on the cake.

I could be an all-or-nothing person like Dr. Phil and tend to the spot(s) on my carpet and clean out all my junk drawers, but then I wouldn't have time to play Uno with my son, take my dog for a walk, or enjoy ten precious minutes alone with a cup of coffee.

The more I stew about Dr. Phil’s philosophy, the more I’m convinced he is mucking up the whole concept of balance. (And, ironically, isn’t balance one of those subjects that Oprah herself loves to wax poetic about?) Instead of feeling compelled to assign meaning to every single aspect of our lives, maybe we should grant ourselves permission to be a little lax now and then. Because, Dr. Phil, I do not believe the way I do one thing is the way I do everything else. I give my family my best, not my screens.

I’m probably overreacting to Dr. Phil’s column, but it’s safe to say I’m finished with him for the day. “I am perfectly capable of living my best life in spite of – or maybe even because of – the orange peels trapped under the seats of my car,” I say to Dr. Phil, shutting the magazine on his smug face. “And that is something I know for sure.”